Scott Hardie | December 9, 2019
Maybe it's just because I read too much entertainment news, but I've seen a lot of coverage of the Golden Globe nominations today, and I see lots of excited talk about them in general at this time of year. I know they've marketed themselves as a respectable award ceremony after many years of being sort of a joke in Hollywood, but I still really, really don't get why anyone takes them seriously.

The Golden Globes are voted on by 91 people who are all entertainment reporters. That's it. That's all of the legitimacy that they have. They're not even critics who write opinions; they're reporters.

By contrast, the Academy Awards are voted on by 8000 people and the Emmys by 25,000 people, all of whom are professionals actively working in film and TV production: Writers, directors, actors, designers, composers, editors, and so on.

I can't think of a situation where so few people who are so unqualified to hold serious opinions are taken so seriously. Funeratic's annual best-of rankings are scarcely less legitimate.

There are all kinds of other awards in Hollywood if the Oscars aren't to your liking. Why does anyone take the Golden Globes seriously? What am I missing?


Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.


Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Annoying Media Tropes

There are all kinds of annoying tropes in movies and TV. I just wrote about one. Watching Person of Interest lately, there are several more on my mind, because the show leans heavily on these: • Antagonists who act really overtly evil, like threatening to kill each other at every turn, or killing their henchmen for minor failures. Go »

The Little Tugboat That Could

The photos on this web site date back to 1978, but I still think it's pretty cool. (Just wondering, is there any difference between a tugboat and a towboat? Go »

Resident Evil Zero

Are there any Resident Evil fans on here besides Matt? I just finished RE0 and I want to gripe about it. Go »

Halloweening

Have any plans for Halloween? How about a costume? Go »

Ein Kind Der Kunst

(link) When I first heard of a baby being born in an art gallery, I figured it was a silly gesture by the kind of ultra-overachiever parents who play Mozart while the child is still in the womb. Go »

Photo Call

Three users already have new photographs of themselves submitted for the new site (November 1st). Who else wants to replace the photo they've been using for a long time? Go »