Scott Hardie | May 14, 2020
I keep hearing complaints in the public sphere that people's constitutional rights are being infringed by these stay-at-home orders.

And I wonder, which rights specifically?

I may have forgotten something else that's important, but the only part of the U.S. constitution that seems to me to be relevant to this is the first amendment, which guarantees that among other things, the right of the people to peaceably assemble shall not be infringed. But we infringe upon that right in all kinds of specific contexts. Besides restricted areas like military bases and high-level government offices, you cannot peaceably assemble in dangerous areas, like on top of burning buildings or inside derelict condemned structures or on top of bridges being demolished. Right now, the entire public sphere is one big dangerous area. You can still peaceably assemble online, or by phone, or even in public using partitions and social distancing. I don't see how being allowed to stand closer together than 6 feet is guaranteed by the amendment.

I asked a friend, who wrote it off as people not knowing what their actual constitutional rights are, like the Facebook users who cite the first amendment when their post is taken down, as if that amendment applies to a private business entity. But I want to give people the benefit of the doubt, and I want to understand better what the outrage is. So I'm really asking: Is there a real constitutional violation in the stay-at-home orders issued by states and municipalities?

Samir Mehta | May 14, 2020
[hidden by request]

Samir Mehta | May 15, 2020
[hidden by request]

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie


Today's not-guilty verdict in the Casey Anthony trial (no link is necessary) has provided me with the first real feelings I've had since this whole sad thing started, other than mild irritation/bafflement at why this case has captured such attention when so many others like it happen all the time. Go »

Deck the Office Halls

'Tis the season for workplace holiday parties. Do you like them or dread them? Do you have any good stories from them? Go »

The History of

In less than a week, this site will turn ten years old. I bet you didn't know that, and I bet you don't know a lot more revealed in The History of goo. Go »

Dubya on Pootie-Poot

Bush-haters ought to enjoy this satirical piece. It's nothing new, but it's still funny. Go »

Gender Reveal Parties

Have you been to a gender reveal party? Would you even host such a thing? It's where expectant parents cut into a cake in front of family and friends to reveal pink or blue inside, discovering the gender of their baby in front of everybody in their lives. Go »

Macon, Milkman, Morrison

Why does Toni Morrison have to give her characters similar names? The protagonist of Song of Solomon is usually called Milkman because of an incident in his childhood. Go »