Scott Hardie | May 13, 2002
[Minor spoilers...] This movie has its admirers (I know Kevin liked it), but I was disappointed. The whole point is that this world that Ethan Hawke enters is a nightmare, and we're supposed to sympathize with him. But repeatedly, he makes choices that let him stay in the nightmare, forwarding the plot but undermining his character. I couldn't buy it. I was also disappointed by the highly implausible ending, where characters get up after acts of violence that should put them in the emergency ward. The movie is shot and acted like a high-quality, realistic thriller, but look beyond the shine and it's just another dumb, implausible action movie with two tough guys posturing as they beat each other up. I'm glad that Denzel Washington got the Oscar for it (he's deserved one for years regardless of this film), but I don't think it's special in any other way. Comments?

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Fall Over

The end of the goo game's fall season is almost here. The scores are so close: Eight players are within 1000 points of the lead as of this writing, with several more players close behind them. Go »


Sometimes the way to solve a problem is to solve two problems. One of the major reasons why we all don't have flying cars is that they're too dangerous for us to operate. Go »

Journey's End

I canceled my Star Trek game today. It was inevitable, but I held out as long as I could. The blame is partly mine, for laziness and indecision (over ending it) at the end, but also that of certain players who didn't play. Go »

Best Movies of 2020

This has been a weird year for movies, as it has for so many other things, so I don't know how many people out there even saw new movies this year. Go »

Members Only

I'm pleased to announce a long-overdue upgrade for this site. Well, two of them. The first is minor: Rather than "users," I'm now calling all of you "members" across the site, except for a few places where you might be called player. Go »

Regretted Recommendations

Awkward story time: Do you have any tales of making a suggestion to someone that turned out badly? This can be something big such as life advice, or something small like recommending a book or a movie. Go »