Scott Hardie | March 11, 2003
I just saw "The Life of David Gale," and it had a twist ending, but I don't need to give the secret away to discuss it here. Suffice to say, many people, both critics and the general public, disliked the film because of the twist ending. Since I did not (at least not that strongly), I began digging around the web to see specifically why people picked on it. You know what I read? A lot of people saying the twist was really obvious, they figured it out halfway through the movie, blah blah. One guy even bragged about how he figured it out upon reading the one-sentence plot description on the page, which could not possibly have signaled the twist because it didn't provide necessary details.

And so of course, what I'm thinking is that these people just want to give themselves a sense of superiority, because they "outsmarted" the movie instead of being outsmarted by it. Ha, that Alan Parker didn't pull one over on me! Well, fine, maybe you are smart, but don't forget that it's your role as a member of the audience to be duped by a plot twist. It's the fucking point of there being one! It's like being proud of yourself for not being scared by a roller coaster - the whole purpose of riding one is to be scared, moron! There are plot twists that help a movie (The Sixth Sense, The Usual Suspects) and there are plot twists that break a movie (The Life of David Gale, Frailty), but judge each plot twist on its own terms, and how it relates to the film. Don't spread word of mouth about a good movie being bad just because you want people to know you didn't "fall for it."

(I guess it goes without saying, but if you're going to reply to this, please use spoiler warnings.)

Jackie Mason | March 11, 2003
[hidden by request]

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Cultural Amnesia

You can wave a magic wand, and forget exactly one book or movie or TV show or album or video game. Would you use it to erase the memory of something that you hated, or would you use to re-experience for the first time something that you loved? Go »

Assignment: 100 Movie Moments

Create a list of 100 moments you love in movies. If that's too many, scale back your own list. You might draw from your own DVD collection for inspiration (like I did heavily). Go »

Lazy Days

Saturday I melted. Wednesday I finished my Survivor game, Thursday I worked on my Star Trek game, Friday I prepared a session of my Matrix game, and Saturday I ran that session. Go »

Cinema Non Grata

Is there any kind of movie (such as a genre) that you refuse to see, no matter how good its reputation is? Go »

I was Drunk, Your Honor

I don't know if the Carlie Brucia case is of much interest outside of Sarasota – Missing Pretty White Girls have finally fallen out of vogue as news headlines (thank goodness) – but there's been an interesting new twist in the case: The defense attorney is seeking to bolster his case by arguing that Joseph Smith was intoxicated at the time of the killing. Go »

Electing the Antichrist

I've been annoyed for some time by the suggestions that Obama is literally the Antichrist. TIME has just published a review of the movement to date, now that McCain's campaign ads have started riding the bandwagon. Go »