Erik Bates | February 28, 2019
I know the man's name isn't Green, but for the sake of a clever title...

What are your thoughts on the controversy surrounding The Green Book winning the Oscar for Best Picture?

The NYT Podcast The Daily covered it in a recent episode, as well.

Samir Mehta | March 1, 2019
[hidden by author request]

Scott Hardie | March 1, 2019
I haven't seen Green Book, so I can't say from my own experience. I will see it someday, regardless of the controversy. Just because the movie is problematic and clueless in its choices about race does not mean that it is entirely without merit.

Justin Chang of the L.A. Times ripped the Academy for their choice. Considering that his piece was published within minutes of the award being given, it seems to have been written in advance. Perhaps Chang wrote an editorial for each possible winner? It's angry and sharp and makes some great points, but the piece that Erik shared is much more historically comprehensive.

Samir, great summary. I agree completely. There's also the matter of the preferential ballot, which means that if a lot of people name Green Book their #2 or #3 choice, it wins the award even though more people may name Roma or BlacKkKlansman or The Favourite their #1 choice. In other words, the Academy specifically rigged their voting system to favor nice, safe choices like Green Book over striking, bold choices. Nobody seems to care about that! But when it's announced that a few categories won't be aired live and will instead be shown later in the broadcast, people lose their shit.

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Erik Bates

Eels - Shootenanny!

Since it was mentioned in the "Clapping at movies" topic, I thought I'd go ahead and start up the new topic so that one doesn't go completely askew. The new Eels CD, "Shootenanny!" Go »


Lori, you trickster! I just skipped that goo because I figured it would be some obscure anime character. Go »

The Nietzsche Family Circus

I should start this out by saying that I got this from Scott Hardie's XQC. Credit where credit is due, I say. Go »

Relay for Life

Hey gang. Something like this hasn't been done here before, so I don't know what kind of reaction I'm going to get, but I'm going to try it anyway. Go »

We Love the Chronic...les of Narnia

Funniest thing to come out of SNL in quite a while. (link) Go »

Fat Guys Need Not Apply

So I go and order my cap and gown for graduation (yay!) and it came in today. Go »