Scott Hardie | July 7, 2002
This got mentioned in an entry from a few hours ago, but I'm giving it an entry all its own: In your opinion, does "gamer" mean a person who plays video games (XBox, PS2, Gamecube), a person who plays computer games, or a person who plays pen-and-pencil role-playing games?

Personally, I have always (and will always) taken it to mean role-playing games, for the almost ten years now that I've been playing RPGs. A "gamer" is a person who plays RPGs, plain and simple, and "gaming" is the practice of playing RPGs. You know why we need that term? Because we depend on a community for our playing. We have to be able to contact one another to get games going, because by the nature of RPGs, we need each other in order to play them. Consider my current situation in Tampa, trying to find other players, if you don't believe me. So we need to have a term by which we can refer to ourselves in shorthand. "Gamer" is better than "role-playing gamer."

By contrast, video game players need no such term. There's almost no community for players of XBox, PS2, and Gamecube, and they certainly don't need a term by which to quickly refer to themselves. As for PC game players, they do have a community (though they depend on it less than RPG players), but they at least have the option of calling themselves "PC gamers." It's close, and it reserves "gamers" for the crowd that had the term first.

I'm taking this too seriously, I know, but I don't like the theft (intentional or accidental) of a word that is important to the RPG community, especially when it's going to something that I don't like, which is PC gaming. I know that not everybody agrees with me, so weigh in on the matter if you like.

Lori Lancaster | July 7, 2002
[hidden by request]

Erik Nelson | July 7, 2002
"There's almost no community for players of XBox, PS2, and Gamecube" of the most (paid) subscribed to web sites on the internet

Scott Hardie | July 7, 2002
Lori - Easy to write, awkward to say. But I can't say I don't like it.

Erik - So? Two sites I visit frequently, (free) and (paid) both have large communities. But the discourse rarely rises above the level of "this game rules" or "this game sucks." Is IGN different?

Scott Hardie | July 7, 2002
And trading Gameshark codes is not discourse. :-)

Kelly Lee | July 8, 2002
Who the hell cares?

One note though, I once told a girl at college that scott and I are role-players, and she thought I meant in bed. So don't say your a role-player, unless you are.

Matthew Preston | July 8, 2002
No wonder my parents give me angry and quizical looks when I say that!

Scott Hardie | July 8, 2002
I give up. I think Kelly's first statement put it best.

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

But I Play One on TV

Police officers have a dangerous job with potential for lots of exciting moments. Trial lawyers can be theatrical and win justice for the little guy. Go »

Trek Again

CBS is launching a new Star Trek series, featuring new characters. It has a high enough budget for the necessary special effects, but since it's on a streaming platform, the need for high ratings isn't as strong as it would be on broadcast. Go »


Be glad you're not this teenager's parents, or, I suppose, this teenager. Seriously, I know teenagers text a lot, but 333 daily? Go »

Hitch's Hustle

I saw a short documentary about Alfred Hitchcock the other night. It showed some of his many cameo roles on-screen in his films, and clips from when he hosted his own long-running TV series Alfred Hitchcock Presents, and assorted other media appearances like TV commercials that he made and many broadcast interviews that he gave. Go »

Vanilla Sky

The advertising for "Vanilla Sky" deserves praise for not revealing the bigger secrets of the film, and the magnitude of these secrets keeps increasing as the film gets closer and closer to its big finish. Go »


Strunk & White's writing advice to omit needless words is a fertile idea for creative experiments, because of elegance in simplicity. Go »