Scott Hardie | January 19, 2019
Should J.K. Rowling have stopped producing more Harry Potter content after the publication of the 7th book, the final in the original series? Since then, she continued dropping details on Twitter that added more details to the canonical story line, then she started writing short stories on the Pottermore website, then she produced a two-part stage play, then came the five-part film series Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find them, and the series shows no signs of stopping.

This is a better way to put it: Would the Harry Potter story be stronger if it was over? Does having a clear beginning-middle-ending structure serve an epic tale better? Is the tale diminished by having an infinite line of follow-up material? OR, does each new piece of content make the series stronger and better? Should it keep growing as long as fans are hungry for more?

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie


Is anybody else at least a little tempted to enter this contest? Go »

More Polls!

With all the polls I want to put up today, I got to thinking that maybe Jackie was on to something. I could program a simple radio-button poll for a sidebar on the site, and provide a form for authors to create their own polls. Go »

Post No Cones

Coming home from work, I found two pine cones in our closed mailbox, without explanation. The floor is open to speculation as to the reason. Go »


Google got a lot of attention recently for its map of America's most misspelled words. Do you have any thoughts on the map? My primary thought is that the map has its own Go »

500 Errors

Funeratic is currently experiencing intermittent PHP errors that result in the "500 Internal Server Error" messages that you are probably seeing, as well as the failure to load many of the images on the site. I have determined that it's not an issue with Go »

The Science of Spoilers

If you avoid spoilers for movies and books so that you can enjoy their surprises, then a new study suggests that ur doin it wrong. Regardless of genre, test subjects consistently enjoyed a story far more when they were told the ending in advance, although Go »

Go for the Gold!

Predict this year's Oscar winners and earn a prize!