Scott Hardie | May 8, 2003
Should a prisoner of war be called a hero when s/he was stupid or cowardly to become a POW in the first place? I didn't know it, but according to this article, POWs were derided until only recently, when society began to consider them heroes instead. (And the complaints are coming from the veterans, not the peaceniks, for a change.) I'm all for respecting a POW because of the sacrifice that s/he made for the country, but now that I think about it, calling one a hero does seem to be a misnomer and to cheapen the term. What do you think?

Anna Gregoline | May 8, 2003
I don't like when anyone is called a hero for something they had no choice but to go through.

Jeff Flom | May 8, 2003
Looking real quick like on google I found a site that said appx. 91,000 servicemen were taken prisoner by the Wehrmacht in W.W. II. To elevate everyone of these people to hero status would be difficult. Bear in mind this does not include those taken prisoner by the Japanese.
P.O.W.'s are hero's now because their numbers are more manageble -- how many P.O.W.'s in operation Iraqi Freedom, 7 or 9?

Scott Hardie | May 8, 2003
Psychic shock: Just for fun, I looked up 'hero' in the dictionary, and it said, "...a long crusty roll split lengthwise and filled with meats and cheese (and tomato and onion and lettuce and condiments)" and for a moment, I thought, Iraqi torture has really gotten bizarre.

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Professional Past and Future

I made the original version of this web site on a whim back in college when I was bored one weekend, and it just kept growing. Go »


If anyone reading this is a "birther," then I sincerely apologize for the condescension to come. I try to be a fair person, but I'm just no longer willing to give birthers the benefit of the doubt. Go »

Fellow Democrats: Prepare to Lose, Again

Democratic voters like me will lose another ounce of hope for our party with the welcoming of Bob Casey into the Pennsylvania senate race against Rick Santorum. Go »

We're All Giant Crab-Men, I Tell You!

Kelly and I saw this nature/science show on PBS last night about researchers who were trying to find the first creature to walk on land. Go »

Born to Lose

I have just joined a fantasy hockey league with friends. I know nothing more about hockey than the average non-fan on the street. Go »

Mood Ringer

Everyone is up in arms about Facebook's mood study in which it deliberately tried to make its audience sad. Go »