Scott Hardie | April 13, 2003
So last night, we were discussing animal politics, as in vegetarianism and fur coats and laboratory animals and so on. I used the word "murder" to refer to the killing of an animal in general, and my tone should have indicated that I wasn't using "murder" in a political sense like the PETA people do, just as a term for killing. Immediately I got pounced on by the others, who claimed strongly that it wasn't murder for various reasons (man was meant to eat meat, medical testing on animals saves lives, et cetera). I find it interesting, now that I've looked it up in the dictionary, that none of them claimed it wasn't murder to kill an animal because the actual definition of the word murder is "the killing of a human being." Anyway, none of us had access to a dictionary last night, so that point is moot, but have we all become so politicized that someone can't just use a word in a sentence without it being seen as some kind of political statement?

Erik Bates | April 13, 2003
[hidden by request]

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

The Return of the King

I've said most of what I wanted to say in my TMR. I thought this was the best film in the trilogy, marginally better than the first because it was able to build on what had come before instead of being saddled with the task of setting everything up. Go »

Vanilla Sky

The advertising for "Vanilla Sky" deserves praise for not revealing the bigger secrets of the film, and the magnitude of these secrets keeps increasing as the film gets closer and closer to its big finish. Go »

Brexit Redux

Today's news. I don't follow this super-closely, so let me see if I understand the chain of events correctly here: 1) Prime minister David Cameron thinks the UK is soundly pro-EU, but there are a few niggling voices of opposition as he prepares to launch new pro-EU initiatives, so to quell any doubt and build momentum for his plans, he calls for a public vote that will put the matter to rest. Go »

Fall TV

Seen any good new shows debuting this season? I've heard good things about Last Resort and 666 Park Avenue as campy fun, both of which wear their Lost influences on their sleeve (and in one case, their cast). Go »


Okay, so it's a hit: The numbers support it ($114 million is the early projection, shattering the record), and everyone I've talked to about it has said it's fantastic. Go »

First Day of School

Today was the first day of my last semester of college. I had planned, without telling anyone, on attending every class this semester. Go »