Scott Hardie | October 6, 2019
I recently read an article listing the signature film of every major city. I think it's a decent list, and not least because the first two titles are two of my favorite movies and the third is one of Kelly's.

Two things I wonder:

1) What do you make of the list? Do other movies come to mind for you for some of these cities?

2) What is the signature film of your area? What do you think of it?

Scott Hardie | October 13, 2019
My area has some eclectic titles, from Woody Harrelson's Palmetto, to Marvel's The Punisher, to Alfonso Cuarón's Great Expectations, to Dolphin Tale and its sequel, to (ugh) Cop & ½. I haven't seen it, but the best-regarded is probably The Greatest Show on Earth. Sarasota has long been the winter home and retirement home of circus performers; a circus museum is one of our key attractions and John Ringling's name is on everything here from streets to schools to, well, museums. It's fitting that a circus movie best represents this area.

Erik Bates | October 14, 2019
St. Louis was a pretty obvious choice, I suppose.

But I think the St. Louis scene from Vacation should count, as well.

Steve West | October 14, 2019
Most Washington DC films are political or agency in nature like All the Presidents Men, The Bourne Legacy, Air Force One, etc. (I was okay with each). But the films I like most had a different spin on DC like St. Elmo's Fire (goofy fun), The Day the Earth Stood Still, Die Hard 2, The Exorcist and Damn Yankees. Superheroes seem to thrive here like Ant Man and Captain America. But my favorite scenes are from Forrest Gump (on the Mall and in the White House).

Scott Hardie | December 7, 2019
Funeratic members in the St. Louis metro area: Do you watch Superstore, and if so, what do you make of the show's interstitial scenes, which portray locals as absurdly selfish and self-absorbed? (It's not really about St. Louis, of course. The show could be set anywhere. But I'm still curious.)

Erik Bates | December 8, 2019
I love Superstore. It's hilarious. As for the referenced scenes, I never took them to be representative of our area.

I get a kick out of them mentioning local landmarks, suburbs, and streets, though. They've done their research!

Funny tid-bit: as far as I can tell, this store is supposed to be in St. Louis, and is supposed to be a stand-in for Walmart.

There are no Walmarts in the city limits.

Samir Mehta | December 8, 2019
[hidden by request]

Scott Hardie | December 9, 2019
Yeah, that show could easily be set in my part of Florida. People are definitely like that here. For example, there's a nearby Mexican restaurant that has $1 tacos on Tuesdays. The place is always swarmed on Tuesday nights and the parking lot overflows, to the point where people literally park on graves in the old grassy graveyard next door. And there's a Taco Bell just a block away selling tacos for the same price with no wait on every night of the week. People are weird.

Erik, I wonder if they picked St. Louis in part because of the lack of Walmarts? LIke maybe no one store could sue and say they're mocking our store specifically? Even if that's true, I bet part of their decision was just wanting a recognizable Midwestern city with no cultural baggage.

Samir, I wasn't specifically aware of a difference, but I'm sure it's like that with many major cities. I grew up near Chicago and the city definitely had a distinct identity from the suburbs, but it's far easier to tell people I'm from Chicago than from a little town on the western outskirts of the metro area that they probably haven't heard of. Only fellow Chicagoans have objected when they learn that I'm misrepresenting where I'm really from.

Steve, I never responded specifically to your comments earlier, but I feel the same way about the DC area on screen, as in, that's a good representative list and I'm fond of Forrest Gump too.

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Human Decency

An amusing story today, if you enjoy schadenfreude for rich kids in Silicon Valley: There's quite a bit of venom being spat at Randi Zuckerberg, former marketing director of Facebook and sister of Mark Zuckerberg, over her accusing a friend of lacking human decency for sharing a private photo with the world, as if that's not the sort of thing that Facebook does all the time, and in fact has made her rich. Go »

So It's Come to This

Butt candles. Go »

The Shutdown

One of the good things about being so busy for the last few weeks is that I've mostly been unable to follow the news. Go »

Not So Fonda

Missouri Man Spits Tobacco Juice on Jane Fonda: (link) (link) In this story, I don't much about his political stance or hers, but I have to admire the guts it took for him to make such a crystal-clear statement of his opinion. Go »

The Psychopathology of Ferris Bueller

Reading one critic's jeering of Ferris Bueller's Day Off on the occasion of its 25th anniversary re-release -- I'm glad to know I'm not the only person on Earth who doesn't adore it -- got me thinking about Jon Ronson's The Psychopath Test, a recent book that explores the plight of diagnosed psychopaths, who cannot be treated and cannot be released. Go »

Want to Go Boldly?

I'm probably being foolish to consider it at this point in time, but I have this terrible urge to get a Star Trek game going. Go »