Since I'm a fan of Survivor and I missed the first halves of early seasons when they aired, lately I've rented them on DVD to see what I missed. And it's given me an opportunity to reflect on how the show has changed over twelve seasons.

The first two seasons had a special quality that has largely been missing every since, which is the genuineness of the cast. Nearly everyone in Australia seemed to show their real selves instead of playing a role like an actor; these days it's so rare that when someone genuine like Rupert or Cirie makes it on the show, they win a groundswell of adoration from the audience. This has slightly weakened the series, but the power of it is still evident. As much as I and other fans enjoy playing armchair survivor about player strategy – I was thrilled when I calculated a 12-point plan for how Amber could have still won when she seemed doomed with her only ally voted out – the real core of the series is human values.

When the show is merely good, it transcends the silly label of "reality television" and isn't about a bunch of liars and cheats, but about people discovering strengths and values they didn't know they had (or didn't have). When the show is at its very best, it's a meditation on civilization itself. There are principled people mixed in with liars and backstabbers, and sometimes one kind wins and sometimes the other, but the point isn't who wins or which strategy is best; it's that there are so many different kinds of people and you're one yourself, and life can be rewarding or punishing depending on how you choose to live it. It's about the human social experience, and that's a mighty accomplishment for a show that could just be about people in swimwear bickering on a beach.

As a fan, I also gained appreciation for something they've done in almost every season since, which is swap the tribes. It always bugs me that just when real relationships are forming, the producers yank the rug out from under the players for a cheap shock, but now I get it. Without a tribal swap in the first half, you get Australia, where the two tribes merged with absolutely zero possibility of integration because loyalty to the original group was ironclad by then. It's boring, and it's repeated itself in the limited tries it has been given ever since. Here's to more tribal swaps in the future, and more of Survivor in general. I thought my interest in the series was waning, but now it's stronger than ever.


One Reply to Revisiting Survivor: Australia

Steve Dunn | August 1, 2006
To me the most startling thing about the first season is how long it took for the concept of "alliance" to take hold. Week after week, it seemed as though the players really didn't know that Richard was leading a group of four. Week after week, people kept voting based on "merit" and so on.

Now, the players try to settle into groups of four almost as soon as they hit the beach on the first day. The players' experience of watching the game has dramatically affected their strategy.


Logical Operator

The creator of Funeratic, Scott Hardie, blogs about running this site, losing weight, and other passions including his wife Kelly, his friends, movies, gaming, and Florida. Read more »

Things You Realize at the Top of a 40-Story Ferris Wheel

Kelly and I just got back from a two-day getaway to Orlando to celebrate our anniversary. No theme parks; we've been to them many times and they're jammed with people right now anyway. We tried small local attractions instead. Go »

Mario in Hell

Classic video game fans have been modding their favorite programs for years to make insanely weird and difficult levels. What does it sound like to play Super Mario Bros. in Hell? Go »

Thorough Performance Reviews

I'm not around much this week because it's time for the annual performance reviews at work. I'm staying up till the wee hours each night writing the reviews so that the two-day marathon of face-to-face chats at the end of the week will go well. It's a win-win: For the employees doing a great job, it's my chance to offer serious praise without it sounding phony or arbitrary. Go »

Parking Lot Pun

Overheard from an elderly woman whose groceries were being lifted into her trunk by a teenaged boy: "When you're as old as I am, the world is your hoister." Go »

Scott's Pet Peeve #8446

Not all mobile phones mix a qwerty keypad with their main numerical keypad, but I have an old Blackberry that does. That makes me especially frustrated by companies that only provide a letter-based phone number without showing a numerical alternative (800-LIKE-THIS). I just went to cancel Nutrisystem, and of course they require you to call a counselor rather than just cancel online, and the only number they give is 888-459-THIN. Go »

Rocky

Let's take a moment to mourn Rocky Aoki, who lived one hell of an interesting life. And that article barely even mentions his kids (in the sidebar), who have their own interesting lives. Go »