Scott Hardie: “It was ok.”

This is a violent crime movie without much violence or crime, and has a hero who rejects both despite the pressures on him. I can appreciate what writer-director J.C. Chandor was trying to say about morality, but his protagonist comes across as more naive than noble. Perhaps a less opaque actor than Oscar Isaac might have made his motivations clearer.

It's not a bad little drama, but it's not terribly satisfying, and nearly every character is unlikeable. Its sprawling cast, gloomy photography, and foreboding sense of dread make it feel like a presige cable drama condensed into a two-hour feature. The trouble and expense that the crew undertook to recreate 1981 must have been immense, because it really does seem like a time machine was involved.

− September 20, 2015 • more by Scottlog in or create an account to reply

Samir Mehta: Bummer - I've been really excited to see this. "All is Lost" is one of my favorite recent movies and I also loved "Margin Call". − September 22, 2015 • more by Samir

Scott Hardie: Your mileage may vary. It has a 90% on the Tomatometer, so I'm certainly in the minority. I thought it was well made; it just didn't move me, and I had some trouble with its moral premise. − September 22, 2015 • more by Scott

Want to join the discussion? Log in or create an account to reply.

write your own review of A Most Violent Year

Other Movies from 2015


Samir Mehta says, "It ruled." Go »

Jurassic World

Erik Bates and Scott Hardie say, "It was ok." Samir Mehta says, "It sucked." Go »

A Grand Night In: The Story of Aardman

Scott Hardie says, "It was ok." Go »

Inherent Vice

Scott Hardie says, "It was ok." Go »


Scott Hardie says, "It was ok." Go »


Scott Hardie says, "It ruled." Samir Mehta says, "It sucked." Go »