Scott Hardie | September 20, 2022
Since Tragic Comedy seems to have turned into a way for us to ask each other stuff that we don't understand, here's something that I've been wondering that I can't find explained online:

I keep hearing in the news about unions being formed by workers in this Amazon warehouse or workers in that Starbucks shop.

Why isn't there a nationwide union for each? There should be a "warehouse workers union" for the former, or a "baristas union" or "fast food workers union" for the latter, similar to the national unions for health care workers and auto workers and so on.

It should not be up to each individual location to unionize. Setting up and operating a union requires a tremendous amount of work, and leaves the workers vulnerable to shenanigans by the company, because even when standing together, there aren't enough people at that one location to make a difference. Banding together at the nationwide level seems much more efficient and effective.

What gives?

Scott Hardie | September 20, 2022
To clarify, I don't mean that all Amazon or Starbucks workers across the country should simultaneously form a union together, which would be way too hard to organize. I mean that a national union should be founded, and then work should go into converting each location to join that existing large union rather than forming its own tiny union.

Samir Mehta | September 20, 2022
[hidden by request]

Scott Hardie | September 22, 2022
Thank you! That makes sense. That's the missing link. :-)

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie


A lot of fuss has been made twice over Serene Branson's spouting of nonsense at the Grammy presentation, first for how silly the video was and then for how sociopathic we're all becoming for having the sick sense of humor to laugh at a poor woman suffering a medical emergency. Go »


An additional note for my entry yesterday about the PS2 vs. the Gamecube: There's now a new black mark against the Gamecube. Go »


Since it was brought to my attention by one user, I was just wondering something. Does anybody realize that my slogan "if you've only checked it once today, you haven't checked it at all" is making fun of Disney? Go »

The Last Toni Morrison Entry for a While, I Promise

For an extra credit paper, I had to compare Paradise and Song of Solomon. In discussing it with Kelly (thanks for the help! Go »

We Never Start Working for You

Just lodging a complaint in my little weblog world where I can pretend that shit like this matters: I'm ticked at Verizon Wireless. Go »

Summer 2021

Congrats on the solo solution, Russ! That was a tough goo. Go »