Scott Hardie | May 16, 2020
I saw a short documentary about Alfred Hitchcock the other night. It showed some of his many cameo roles on-screen in his films, and clips from when he hosted his own long-running TV series Alfred Hitchcock Presents, and assorted other media appearances like TV commercials that he made and many broadcast interviews that he gave. Even his logo is his face. And this documentary mentioned how this very high profile as a director, where he was often more famous than anyone in his cast, led to him being the first director taken seriously by the public and acclaimed as a master filmmaker.

...But it's 2020 now. We understand media manipulation and constant self-promotion better. We've seen "lifestyle" figures like Kim Kardashian and Oprah Winfrey and Martha Stewart master the act of marketing themselves -- there is no separate brand; they are the brand. Donald Trump even made it to the White House by marketing himself aggressively as a brand.

So while I certainly don't dismiss Hitchcock's skill as a filmmaker, I do wonder if:

1) Part of his reputation can be chalked up to his higher visibility than his contemporaries. (That is to say, of all of the good directors of that era, he got more attention and thus an inflated reputation.)

2) His media appearances allowed him to shape his own reputation directly, in ways that academia/critics/scholars haven't yet undone.

3) He deserves way more credit for media manipulation than he gets. His films didn't just become hits on their own!

4) He ever got tired of the endless media appearances. It must have been exhausting, especially considering how prolific he was as a filmmaker at the same time.

Is Hitchcock deserving of some degree of re-appraisal? Or am I just making a very late realization about him that everyone else already understood long ago?

Scott Hardie | October 16, 2022
Some of you must aware of this, but it's news to me now that Hitchcock destroyed Tippi Hedren's career for not sleeping with him. His manipulation of public image was no doubt a factor in his ability to escape consequences for that, but more importantly, it put him in a position of power and influence to be able to make such a demand in the first place. I already had a poor opinion of him due to the aforementioned documentary; now I don't think it could get any worse.

When I think of media manipulation, I also think of Buckminster Fuller. I was recently reading about the celebrated futurist and inventor, and how everything that you know about him is basically bullshit. He made up many of his credentials (paying for faux honorary degrees from shady institutions), stole ideas from his students, did not do his job consistently as a professor (gave rambling hours-long lectures once in a while but otherwise didn't show up), and produced useless ideas that don't actually work in reality (like the famous geodesic dome, which was a student's idea anyway), What did he spend most of his time on if not inventing and teaching? It was on self-promotion: Making endless media appearances and going anywhere that would give him an award or other honor so that he could continue pretending to be important. Being "Buckminster Fuller" was his full-time job.

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Freebie Week (Goo)

Programmers love events like daylight savings time, leap years, and other special occasions that screw with our carefully timed scripts. Go »

Cultural Imperialism on a Personal Scale

One of the few things that my mom and I have in common is a love of movies. Though we don't like the same genres, good movies transcend these kinds of preferences. Go »

Extra Life 2020

I had an absolute blast at last year's Extra Life event, that 24-hour marathon of gaming for charity. Go »

Patriotic Suicide

Here's the sad tale of a young man who took Bush's re-election a little too hard. (link) Some folks joke about moving to Canada; others get a little more dramatic. Go »

Fastest or First?

Both of these options have been controversial in the goo game before, but I'm curious which has more support. Go »

Trekkies Revolt and Make Their Own Show

(quoted from StudioBriefing) Saying that it "will surely be regarded as one of the best science-fiction 'fan film' projects of all time," the St. Go »