Scott Hardie | January 26, 2020
Is anybody else watching this new series? What do you think of it?

I have plenty of thoughts and reactions after the first episode, but foremost among them is how nice it feels to have a show built off of my Star Trek for a change. I was never a big fan of the original series, so to have the original spinoffs and Discovery and the JJ Abrams movies mine that original series for nostalgia over and over again got a little tiresome. At last, here's a series that revisits the 90s era for nostalgia, the era that I loved most, and it feels great. If we somehow get a Deep Space Nine continuation, I'll be in heaven.

Erik Bates | January 26, 2020
I watched episode 1 yesterday. It is so good.

For starters, Patrick Stewart is just a treasure. It's good to see Brent Spiner, and I hope that we get to see more of him.

What I'm reading online, there seems to be a lot of connection to Nemesis. I need to go back and watch that again, to see if I can make a connection to it.

Scott Hardie | January 26, 2020
Yeah, it's kind of unfortunate that the new show is stuck dealing with the little-loved and mostly-forgotten Nemesis, since that movie left the characters in such specific places. It reminds me of when The X Files was revived on television and had to spend time picking up on story threads from the final two years of the original series, after viewership was well in decline. I'm sure a lot of people who only remembered the peak years of the original were scratching their heads.

Picard moralizes; it's pretty much his defining trait. And it's boring when he adopts a popular opinion, so it's better when he takes the moral high road against the popular opinion or conventional wisdom, as in Insurrection and "The Drumhead" and "The Measure of a Man." This new series doesn't dwell on it, but I couldn't help but notice the modern-day political implications of Picard's position in that TV interview: He treats Romulan refugees as people deserving of humanitarian aid and shelter, even though most of the Federation rejects them. Is it me or is Jean-Luc Picard better qualified than most characters on television to make such a moral stand? I don't think the writers could have found a better vessel for that particular argument.

Erik Bates | January 26, 2020
It did very much feel like "I didn't leave Starfleet. Starfleet left me."


Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.


Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

The Cheat is in Trouble

I just wanted to give notice that I have altered the Goo Rules as they pertain to cheating. (link) I can now optionally suspend a player or players if I discover evidence of their cheating. Go »

Just Curious

Does Entertainment Weekly still publish anything other than lists? Go »

Summer 2011 Season

It's time for a new season in the goo game! Preparing GooCon this weekend took me longer than expected, so I'll have to save the full ten-week schedule for the new goo season until tomorrow or maybe Tuesday. Go »

Winter 2020

The 83rd season of Celebrity Goo Game begins tomorrow. I have some fun things planned for the season that will reveal themselves soon. Go »

False Fast Food Advertising

Thanks to a friend, I came across Alphaila's comparison of fast food products vs. advertisements. A professional photographer took pictures of actual sandwiches at the most attractive angles in a well-lit studio, and couldn't begin to match the promised sandwiches. Go »

A Knack for Old Videos

Compare: The Knack, My Sharona The Strokes, Reptilia Could the same band and their director have traveled through time 25 years to make both videos? Go »