Scott Hardie | July 22, 2018
What do you think of the movement to ban drinking straws?

Samir Mehta | July 22, 2018
[hidden by author request]

Scott Hardie | July 23, 2018
When I first heard about the movement, it was in California, where the state had banned restaurants from giving away straws unless customers asked for them. And I thought that was a sensible moderate approach that would eliminate a lot of needless waste -- I rarely use the straws given to me, for instance -- while still letting the people who want or need straws get them.

Then it became about banning restaurants from even stocking straws at all, which seems excessive, but I suppose people who need them could bring in their own.

But somehow the movement has morphed into banning all straws everywhere, which is dangerous and rightly sparking a backlash.

I do not understand liberal activism's impulse to overreach. Why is incremental change insufficient? The first iteration of this in California would have made a significant environmental improvement without negatively impacting anyone. That should have been enough. We could have lived with it for a while and thought it through before proceeding with more change. Ugh.

Similarly, the left's scientific ignorance is shameful too. The science is fake in the case of the drinking straw ban. People rush into planet-saving and society-improving causes without realizing that they're counter-productive or just plain flawed. I will always favor well-funded research and trials before any significant change in the law.

Samir, I hear you about the viral ideas being the only "good" ones. That sort of thing has long been a problem in animal welfare causes. Everybody wants to help cute animals like puppies and baby seals, but when it's gross animals like insects or slugs or deep-sea creatures, people stop caring.

Samir Mehta | July 24, 2018
[hidden by author request]

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Construction Delays

Has anybody here worked in road construction before? Can anyone tell me why it sometimes takes so long to finish a project? Go »


It's been three weeks since Rock Block launched, and the early rush of mass participation has given way to a few regulars playing constantly. To a large degree that's normal and expected, but to the degree it doesn't have to be that way, I'd like to do so Go »

Members Only

I'm pleased to announce a long-overdue upgrade for this site. Well, two of them. Go »


There's a new "Report Spam Email" button in your control panel. Use this to report if you receive any unsolicited email through your Go »

Singularity Sensation

On the occasion of his passing, what did Stephen Hawking mean to you? Go »

Nobody Checks

From what I can tell, is a legitimate online money-transfer service. Go »