Scott Hardie | December 1, 2018
Our annual rankings of movies is open for voting as of today. I look forward to seeing what movie tops the list.

As superhero movies go, Black Panther was easily the most widely celebrated movie of the year, and it was good. But I thought Infinity War was even better, as both a movie and as a gargantuan logistical accomplishment. (How easy they made it look to keep track of so many main characters and so many simultaneous story threads!) I'm disappointed that Infinity War is stuck in Black Panther's shadow at end of year, but if it means that Marvel, which has turned out exceptionally good entertainment for the last few years, finally gets some awards-season respect, I can live with that.

What do you think the best movies of this year have been?

Samir Mehta | December 5, 2018
[hidden by author request]

Samir Mehta | December 5, 2018
[hidden by author request]

Samir Mehta | December 5, 2018
[hidden by author request]

Scott Hardie | December 31, 2018
Last-minute reminder: Today is your last chance to vote.

Scott Hardie | December 31, 2018
Since Infinity War hit Netflix a week ago, I've watched it four times. I'm more certain than ever that it's not just Marvel's best movie to date, but it's just an excellent movie period, without qualifiers around its genre or brand.

Erik Bates | December 31, 2018
I usually spend December frantically remembering which movies I watched through the year and writing reviews of them.

I don't think it's going to happen this year. My heart just hasn't been in it.

Scott Hardie | January 1, 2019
Happy new year, all! The 2018 list is now final. It features an interesting variety of genres, although superheroes continue to dominate our annual list just like they dominate movie theaters in general. This is the first time that all participants chose the same #1 movie, putting it way out ahead of the rest of the pack. I can't wait to see the movies on the list that I haven't yet! Here's hoping for a great 2019 in film. I'm grateful to Evie and Matthew for contributing. :-D

Erik, are there any standouts worth mentioning here?

Erik Bates | January 1, 2019
We saw the new Mary Poppins today. It was endearing and an absolute joy.

I agree with the super hero dominance this year.

I'd like to echo Samir with the mention of Won't You Be My Neighbor?

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie


You want to know what's disgusting? This is disgusting. Go »

Saddam's Capture

Well, if no one else will introduce the topic, I will. I congratulate the troops and President Bush on this accomplishment. Go »

Electing the Antichrist

I've been annoyed for some time by the suggestions that Obama is literally the Antichrist. TIME has just published a review of the movement to date, now that McCain's campaign ads have started riding the bandwagon. Go »


Yeah, like these aren't going to get stolen often. Go »

The Cartoon

The infamous chimp cartoon seems to be like the young woman / old woman optical illusion, inspiring widely different interpretations of the same image. The first time I looked at it, yeah, it seemed pretty obvious that the chimp was Obama, and I could ima Go »

Wanted: Wise Old Leaders

Peggy Noonan just wrote a piece in the WSJ about how wise old leaders have been rejected for the last two generations, to the detriment of the nation and the world. I don't know if that's entirely true; Ted Kennedy and Robert Byrd served until their recen Go »

Go for the Gold!

Predict this year's Oscar winners and earn a prize!