Scott Hardie | January 10, 2019
The Sopranos turns 20 today. What did (or does) the show mean to you?

Erik Bates | January 10, 2019
Never watched the show. I was a fan of the theme song, though!

Steve West | January 10, 2019
It made for wonderful binge watching for about 3-4 months. We got through the whole set alternating with Deadwood and The West Wing. I could not endorse any of them more.

Scott Hardie | January 10, 2019
I loved that show. I still do. I still quote it in my head all the time, or find myself drawing connections between the drama on the show and other stories or real life. It was so funny, and so well acted. Its place in history as a landmark show that changed television is assured; I can't praise it any more than it already has been praised.

As for the 20th anniversary specifically? One weakness of the show is that it doesn't age well, due to it being so specifically of its early-2000s mindset. It was groundbreaking at the time, but if a new viewer like Erik tried to watch it in today's world, its power would be diminished. The sudden death of Jim Gandolfini casts a pall over it retroactively, too.

The West Wing is also excellent. I need to see Deadwood, and not just for what I'm told is some extremely creative swearing, exceeding even that of the Soprano crime family.

Samir Mehta | January 10, 2019
[hidden by author request]

Steve West | January 10, 2019
You nailed it, Samir. What a supporting cast! Lorraine Bracco, Frank Vincent, and John Heard all shone.

Want to participate? Please create an account a new account or log in.

Other Discussions Started by Scott Hardie

Greendale Alumni Association

Has anyone else here seen the series Community? I'm a few years behind as usual, but I just watched the entire run and wouldn't mind discussing our thoughts with fellow fans, if there are any here. Go »

Maybe Results Imaginary

Kelly and I were just talking about this the other day, and then Friday's XKCD hit on the same idea: Why does one part of the brain lighting up in an MRI "prove" anything about what the subject is thinking? The metho Go »

Site Updates

Some users have mentioned how hard it is to keep up with little unannounced updates to the site, like the several new play rules recently added to Rock Block. To that end, I have created a Site Updates page to announce all changes to the site, large and s Go »


People keep asking after Kelly and me as Irma approach Go »

Spam Part II: Humor

I suppose this isn't spam, just something that an idiot sent to me, but I thought it was funny. From: "Nicholas Surawski" Subject: Fwd: You Will Be Off Hotmail In 10 Days Date: Thu, 19 Jul 2001 15:48:34 +1000 >>>>>Dear Hotmail User, Our hotmail Go »

Sad Sad Song

What's the saddest song that you know? Go »