publication date: Monday, September 16, 2019 (part of Fall 2019)

category: Hoaxes

clue: Her YA novel became a handbook for scamming your way onto the bestseller list for a single day.

explanation: In 2017, Sarem's debut novel Handbook for Mortals entered the New York Times bestseller list at #1, but was pulled 23 hours later amid mounting evidence that Sarem had gamed the system, which she admitted in later interviews. more…

difficulty: medium

solved by: Russ Wilhelm, Steve West, Chris Lemler, Matthew Preston, Richard Slominsky, and Erik Bates

Similar Goos

Michelle Ann Williams

This renowned Jamaican scientist is a dean at Harvard, which is in Cambridge, not in nearby Manchester-by-the-Sea. Go »

Michelle Toro

In 2016, this swimmer was too busy winning an Olympic medal for Canada to have been nominated for a Tony Award for Blackbird on Broadway. Go »

Michelle Williams

This former member of Destiny's Child starred in Chicago on Broadway, not in Brokeback Mountain. Go »


She's a YouTube-based pop star who released her debut in 2018, not an animated character who debuted in 1990. Go »

Sylvia Browne

This self-described psychic, now two years deceased, had critics seeing red (and brown) when her claims in several missing-persons cases turned out to be false. Go »

Cate Blanchett

On-screen, she's been to Middle-earth, Asgard, San Francisco, Elizabethan England, Golden-Age Hollywood, Cinderella's castle, the Met Gala, Sherwood Forest, and her native Australia. Go »