publication date: Thursday, January 12, 2012 (part of Winter 2012)

category: Music

clue: I really screwed up last season and hurt players by not crediting their guesses for this singer instead of the arsonist that I mislabeled his picture as. I hope they'll do the Christian thing and forgive me.

explanation: Cottrell was a Christian singer. more…

do-over: This was a "do-over" goo, inspired by incorrect guesses for a previous goo.

solved by: Russ Wilhelm, Steve West, Samir Mehta, LaVonne Lemler, Chris Lemler, Justin Woods, Richard Slominsky, Joanna Woods, Denise Sawicki, Mike Rothstein, Steve Dunn, Erik Bates, Aaron Shurtleff, and Ryan Dunn

trivia: This goo was inspired by incorrect guesses for the goo of William Cottrell.

Do Overs: Ask George Lucas: No matter how final it was the first time, anything can be made better if you get to take a second (or third, or fourth) crack at it. These five celebrities were incorrect guesses made for previous goos. Here's your chance to get them right this time.

Similar Goos

Brandy Norwood

Like Cheryl Burke, this singer competed on Dancing with the Stars, but she's better known for her UPN sitcom. Go »

Piper Palin

It's tough to be confused for your older sisters, but at least you're not a baby boy being confused for them. Go »

Charlotte Church

She got her start in classical music before transitioning to better-selling pop music. Go »

Zach Weiner

Like Matthew Inman, he writes and draws a webcomic named for breakfast cereal, but his is best read on Saturday mornings. Go »

Kate Winslet

Like Emmy Rossum, this six-time Oscar nominee starred in a movie about a sinking ship, but hers was just a little more successful financially. Go »

Barbra Streisand

This beloved singer and actress is a well-oiled machine when it comes to earning awards for her work. Go »